How the YouTube Algorithm Works (Explained in Circles)
Written by Jan Drahoš
A lot of nonsense gets told about the YouTube algorithm. Its basic logic is actually fairly straightforward and can be drawn on a sheet of paper.
One thing matters above all: the algorithm behaves differently for an established channel than for one starting from zero. If you don't know that difference, you'll wonder why something isn't working even though every guide says it should.
Let's go through both.
Three circles of audience
Picture three concentric circles around your channel.
At the centre are subscribers. The loyal core who come back to most new videos.
Around them are returning viewers. They never subscribed, but they come back. They like this type of video, the topics interest them. For a creator these people are more valuable than brand-new audience — they behave almost like subscribers, just without the click.
Furthest out is new audience. People who don't know you. One of your videos appeared on their home screen, they clicked, and that's where it stands.
What happens after publishing on an established channel
Say your channel has been running six months or a year, with subscribers and returning viewers. You publish a new video.
First hour or two. YouTube shows it only to your subscribers. Nobody else. It's gathering data on how good the video is — and it asks the people most interested in your content. Which is logical: if they don't like it, strangers certainly won't.
The following two to four hours. If the video succeeds with the core, returning viewers join in. The audience widens, but these are still people who know you.
Then it goes out. If the video holds up here too, YouTube starts showing it to people with similar interests and similar viewing habits to your core. And it keeps testing. Each further layer is a little more general and less tied to the specific topic.
Where it stops. The moment click-through drops in some layer, or people stop finishing the video. YouTube concludes there's no point continuing and distribution winds down.
And if it doesn't stop? The video goes viral. It reaches people whose interests have nothing to do with the topic.
What this means for scheduling
When a video matters to you, don't publish it while your subscribers are offline. The first hours decide whether the video gets out at all — and in those hours you're judged exclusively by your core.
I'm not saying you should hunt for a magic publishing hour. Only that a regular slot your audience gets used to matters more than it seems.
Why a new channel starts completely differently
Now the second case. New channel, first few videos, no subscribers. And crucially — no audience anywhere else. No Instagram, Facebook, LinkedIn, no newsletter. Nothing to bring people from.
You publish, and YouTube has a problem. There's nobody to show it to first. The inner circles don't exist.
So it releases the video straight into a huge pool of new viewers — people who may have no interest at all. It looks unfair, but the algorithm is working. It picks out those who watched roughly half the video or more, and builds a profile from them: what their viewing habits are, what interests them, who liked it.
Your second, third and fourth videos then go primarily to that profile. Gradually it turns those people into a returning audience — building you the inner circle you didn't have.
The shortcut that speeds this up
If you have an audience elsewhere — Instagram, LinkedIn, a newsletter — and you bring it to the channel right at the start, you hand the algorithm an immediate signal about who to target.
You save months it would otherwise spend finding the viewer profile on its own. It's one of the few things that genuinely helps at launch.
What to take away
The algorithm isn't looking for "good videos" in some abstract sense. It's looking for videos that specific people finish. So there's no point asking what the algorithm wants — ask what your client wants to watch.
And if you're at the start and the numbers show nothing, that isn't necessarily a sign you're doing something wrong. The algorithm is still figuring out who to show you to. That takes a while.
How to turn that into clients rather than just views, I cover in Where to send YouTube viewers. And if you'd like your own channel reviewed, the audit is free.
Keep reading
Jan Drahoš
YouTube Strategist & Marketing for Financial Advisors